Linkfest 2017-03-17: St. Patrick's Feast Day Edition
No evidence to back idea of learning styles
Steven Pinker [among others] writes a letter to the Guardian against currently fashionable learning styles fads in education. In the post pointing to this, Steve Sailer offers a mild counterpoint based on his position that a lot of "neuroscience" findings are better thought of as something like marketing, a real benefit, but nothing lasting like science should be.
Why so many conservative Christians feel like a persecuted minority
Damon Linker pens a sympathetic and critical take on Rod Dreher's The Benedict Option.
Geoarchaeologist Proposes There Was a “World War Zero”
I first came across this idea on Jerry Pournelle's website as the first dark age. This was a period of steep decline that makes the dissolution of the Western Roman Empire seem minor in comparison. In the first dark age, even the memory of writing was lost. When the Greeks began to rebuild, the fortifications of their predecessors were seen as the work of monsters, rather than men, because no one could conceive of building anything as massive. I had not heard the term 'Luwians' to describe the people of the Anatolian peninsula who may perhaps be the 'Sea People' who overran much of the civilized Eastern Mediterranean in that time.
The Fall of Rome and "The Benedict Option"
I'm not really sympathetic to Rod Dreher's Benedict Option, and a big part of the reason is that his metaphor is a really bad description of what actually happened in the fifth century.
When Public Policy meets Elementary Biology
To go along with Ross Douthat's plan to create a series of immodest proposals to try and shift public policy debates into more useful channels, here is Henry Harpending's take on how we should shift welfare policies to take into account human biology. Henry implied at the end of the post that his suggestion needed amendment to prevent bad consequences, but to my knowledge, Henry never published a followup to this before he died, which is a damn shame.
An Oxford comma changed this court case completely
I've always been a fan of the Oxford comma.
Immigrations and Public Finances in Finland Part I: Realized Fiscal Revenues and Expenditures
Emil Kirkegaard posted this on Twitter. The graph in the source report is astonishing.
The originating organization is a Finnish anti-immigration group, but the results astonished just about everyone. The methodology is an attempt to account for all taxes, direct and indirect, as well as government spending of all kinds. I'm not sure I would hang my hat on it, but I'm not sure it's wrong either.
Lean In’s Biggest Hurdle: What Most Moms Want
Any attempt at statistical parity in childcare is doomed to failure, because many women actually like having kids and raising them. This isn't to say that every woman wants kids, or that every woman must stay home, but given the option, many women do choose to either work part-time, or leave work entirely for a period of time.
BOOK REVIEW: SEEING LIKE A STATE
I can't improve on SSC's opening paragraph:
Seeing Like A State is the book G.K. Chesterton would have written if he had gone into economic history instead of literature. Since he didn’t, James Scott had to write it a century later. The wait was worth it.
Right or wrong direction: The nation generally
This Reuters poll on whether the nation is generally going in the right direction is pretty striking. Especially if you compare it to this Gallup poll on President Trump's approval ratings.
I naively expected these results would roughly track [keep in mind the timeframes are very different]. They don't at all, which is pretty interesting.
Consistent Vegetarianism and the Suffering of Wild Animals
I also have a hard time taking complaints about modern animal husbandry seriously.